We are in it for the love of the listen, watch, and play. We want to know your top five and your favorite media memories.

EmailRebelReplay@gmail.com

Hey, we get it. Sometimes stuff doesn’t hit the way you thought it would. Maybe that CD skips. Maybe the cartridge just flashes gray. Maybe you changed your mind. No shame in that. Here’s how to send it back without selling out:

NEW STUFF (STILL SEALED)

Gotta be UNOPENED and in original packaging. Think shrink-wrapped CD perfection  

Return it within 30 DAYS of delivery 

You pay return shipping (sorry, we’re not made of money)

USED STUFF (PRE-LOVED & RAD)

Return it within 30 DAYS of delivery  

Gotta be in the same shape you got it from the Replay racks

You cover shipping (just like trading tapes by mail)

DEFECTIVE? WE GOT YOU.

Something busted or janky? Tell us within 30 DAYS  

We’ll pay return shipping on that fried cartridge or warped vinyl

You get a REPLACEMENT or REFUND – your call

FINAL SALE = NO TAKEBACKS

Some stuff is marked “ALL SALES FINAL.” Think imports, grab bags, or promo stuff.  

• No refunds, no returns, no regrets  

• Choose like you’re in the last aisle of Blockbuster, 1996

NEED TO RETURN SOMETHING?

Email us: EmailRebelReplay@gmail.com  

Send your order # and what’s up.  

We’ll reply fast and keep it cool.

REBEL REPLAY: Because physical media never ghosted you.  

We’re here to take the guess work out of condition descriptions. We make it easy by breaking it all down into six easy-to-understand categories. Not sure how to categorize your stash? Use your best judgement. We’re not here to argue. And honestly, The Rebels (that’s you!) are much smarter than they look. 

NEW

Unopened. Cover in glorious shrinkwrap and/or never sullied by your grimy little hands. 

MINT

Near perfection, like a sub five-minute Super mario Bros. speed run. Seriously, this is a special category. We don’t use this often and reserve this for the best of the best.

EXCELLENT

Very few signs of use. It’s probably not going to get the highest grading, but it looks awesome on a shelf. We call this “collector’s condition” because it’s the standard most serious collectors have.

GOOD

You’d buy it, but you’d think about it for a second. Maybe some dented corners, maybe a scratch or two. Maybe it’s incomplete. These items have a little love showing. That’s ok though, because everything we sell is guaranteed! 

FAIR

Now you’re really thinking about it before buying. It’ll work, but it won’t look pretty doing it. Missing labels, janky sleeves, weird stains are all part of the world of fair. Poor: We will rarely sell (or buy) something in poor condition. Discs where playability isn’t certain, vinyl that looks like it was used by a DJ-to-be, NES games that have weird goop in the corner will all be found in the poor bin. Sigh. Why do people treat media like this?

REBEL REPLAY WANTS YOUR STUFF (THE GOOD STUFF)

Got vinyl you never spin? Games gathering dust? Need money to buy more stuff from Rebel Replay?

Old movies, CDs, tapes, or gear that needs a second life?

We BUY used media – and we keep it simple, fast, and fair.

HOW TO SELL US YOUR STASH

Box up your stuff + ship it to us (your dime)*.

Include a note with your name, contact info, and preferred payment method (Cash App, Zelle, or Venmo).

Wait for us to get it and dig in (we move fast).

*Want a sneak peek at how much you’ll get? Send us an email with a list of what you want to sell. Describe the condition – be honest. Mint means mint, my most excellent friend. We’ll send you an approximate value. Things like condition and version may affect the value. So be as careful as you can when making your list and checking it twice.

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN IT ARRIVES

We evaluate every item within 24 hours.

You get a detailed, item-by-item CASH OFFER.

No ghosting. No “bundle” bullsh*t. Just the facts.

LIKE THE OFFER?

Sweet. We send payment within 24 HOURS via:

• Venmo
• Cash App
• Zelle
• We can even send you a check like it’s 1992 (but who wants to wait for that sweet, sweet cash?)

(You pick. You get paid fast – unless you choose check because snail mail)

DON’T LIKE THE OFFER?

• No hard feelings.
• We’ll ship your stuff BACK TO YOU FOR FREE.
• Seriously. We’re not here to rip people off.

WHAT WE BUY

• Video Games (cartridges, discs, complete-in-box, we’ll consider it all)
• Vinyl Records
• CDs, Tapes, DVDs, Blu-ray
• Cool, weird, or rare stuff – try us (just don’t make it too weird)

WHAT WE DON’T BUY

• Scratched-to-hell discs.
• Bootlegs, repros, burns, or knock-offs (gotta be the official versions).
• Moldy, cracked, or warped stuff.
• Stuff that smells like an ashtray in 1987. Also, please don’t send us stuff the cat peed on. That’s just nasty. 

WANNA TRADE?

• Hey, we’re totally down for that! 
• Send us a list of what you want to trade and what you want from us. 
• We’ll let you know within 24 hours. 
• If we agree as gentlemen do, we’ll send you shipping instructions. 
• Ship us your stuff (soon to be our stuff). 
• Once the package arrives and we confirm everything is present and in the condition described, we’ll ship your new stuff that same day. What could be easier? 

REBEL REPLAY: WE KEEP MEDIA ALIVE

Because this ain’t a landfill – it’s a love letter to the analog era.

Wanna sell? Questions? Email us: EmailRebelReplay@gmail.com and let’s see what you have!