Behind the Counter

Meet Player One and Player Two

Cue intro music. Rebel Replay’s “Behind the Counter” is all about the staff because we want you to know who your fellow Rebels are! 

Ryan Cairney

Ryan has a passion for everything Rebel Replay represents, a community space where people can spend time together talking about all their favorite things related to music, video games, movies, and art. His dream is that Rebel Replay becomes THE cultural hub, where kids and adults alike can spend time and feel a sense of community around media and the core memories associated with it. 

Molly Cairney

Molly’s goal is for Rebel Replay to be a space where anyone can feel a sense of belonging and connection to the community. She aims to achieve this with her eye for design and experience with accessibility. Customer with disabilities will find the same experience and feeling and connection through our strong efforts to make Rebel Replay a friendly space. 

Want to know what we are all about?

Returns

Hey, we get it. Sometimes stuff doesn’t hit the way you thought it would. Maybe that CD skips. Maybe the cartridge just flashes gray. Maybe you changed your mind. No shame in that. Here’s how to bring it back without selling out:

NEW STUFF (STILL SEALED)

Gotta be UNOPENED and in original packaging. Think shrink-wrapped CD perfection  

Return it within 30 DAYS 

You pay return shipping (sorry, we’re not made of money)

USED STUFF (PRE-LOVED & RAD)

Return it within 30 DAYS  

Gotta be in the same shape you got it from the Replay racks

DEFECTIVE? WE GOT YOU.

Something busted or janky? Tell us within 30 DAYS  

You get a REPLACEMENT or REFUND – your call

FINAL SALE = NO TAKEBACKS

Some stuff is marked “ALL SALES FINAL.” Think imports, grab bags, the 2 Buck Bin, or promo stuff.  

• No refunds, no returns, no regrets  

• Choose like you’re in the last aisle of Blockbuster, 1996

REBEL REPLAY: Because physical media never ghosted you.  

Accessibility

Our building is so old it is historic so access can be a challenge but not a Metroid Dread challenge, more like a Metroid Prime challenge. If you need an accommodation, call or email and we will work with you to figure it out. Music, movies, games, and community vibes are for everyone.

Location, Location, Location

Location is everything! And we are located at 18 West Depot Street, Pataskala, Ohio, 43062. Our area has free street parking and a large free public lot a block away.